Action needed to mitigate 'fraudulent' lead generation in insurance

‘Protecting the Protectors’ paper warns

Adam Saville
clock • 2 min read

Large intermediaries and insurer partners are at "serious" risk of being investigated by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) and the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), a new paper has revealed.

According to the ‘Protecting the Protectors' report, published by LifeSearch and Contact State, some life insurance firms are using fraudulent short-term tactics amid misleading advertising, the reselling of consumer data and impersonation of insurance brands.

The report also states that: "Disreputable lead generation activity is driving clawback rates and increasing industry bad debt."

As well as laying out ASA advertising standards and FCA stipulations, the paper shines a light on the practices being used by ‘rogue' online lead generators, while exploring how the life insurance industry can mitigate, control and stamp it out by setting a transparent universal standard of "data exchange and certification".

The report states: "The answer is not to stifle innovation or take a heavy handed regulatory approach. Instead, we believe that the industry should create a ‘gold standard' of lead generation and reward those affiliates, intermediaries and insurers who create better outcomes for the consumer.

"To do this we believe that every single life Insurance lead should have an accompanying certificate created at the source and start of the customer journey by an independent technology business. That certificate will certify the authenticity of the data, the advertising used and the veracity of the compliance information."

‘Mission'

LifeSearch CEO Tom Baigrie said: "We are pleased to co-author this paper, which we hope begins to address many of the poor, and often fraudulent, practices being used to generate leads in the protection market. The result is often consumer detriment, which is potentially damaging for all parties across the industry in the long term."

Alain Desmier, managing director of Contact State, added: "Our unambiguous mission is to remove fraudulent lead generators from the protection industry. We're very proud to stand alongside LifeSearch and make recommendations in this paper that we believe will lead to much better customer outcomes."

Oliver Rayner of Caspian Insurance Services described the issue as an "urgent" one that "needs to be addressed".

"I have a particular concern with the type of misleading and fraudulent adverts that are being widely used to generate consumer interest in protection products," he said. "Caspian Insurance was the first life insurance intermediary to use Contact State and I am very supportive of the recommendations within this paper."

More on Protection

Consumer Duty: Two years on – the protection impact

Consumer Duty: Two years on – the protection impact

Impact on the market and next steps

Jaskeet Briah
clock 01 August 2025 • 5 min read
Alcohol, Britain, one night stands and smartwatches… what does Gen Z really think?

Alcohol, Britain, one night stands and smartwatches… what does Gen Z really think?

'Listening to younger people is as refreshing as it is challenging. But ignoring it isn't an option'

Kevin Carr
clock 24 July 2025 • 4 min read
Group life cover excluded from IHT liability

Group life cover excluded from IHT liability

HMRC decision on protection and inheritance tax

Cameron Roberts
clock 23 July 2025 • 2 min read

In-depth

Targeted support: 'Watch this space!' – unknowns persist

Targeted support: 'Watch this space!' – unknowns persist

Industry awaits final details of the FCA’s proposals

Isabel Baxter
clock 19 August 2025 • 7 min read
Polling high – should advisers bank on Reform UK holding on?

Polling high – should advisers bank on Reform UK holding on?

Nigel Farage-led party's policies would likely mean big tax changes if Reform came into power

Isabel Baxter
clock 30 July 2025 • 7 min read
Financial planning 'badly' needed PFS £1m talent pledge – what next?

Financial planning 'badly' needed PFS £1m talent pledge – what next?

Considerations include representation, showing not telling, and small business support

Jen Frost
clock 29 July 2025 • 6 min read