Pensions Regulator warns new master trusts pose risks to members

Less regulatory scrutiny than contract-based alternatives

clock • 1 min read

The Pensions Regulator (TPR) has warned there are real risks from new master trusts being subject to far less regulatory scrutiny than new contract-based providers in auto-enrolment pension schemes.

The watchdog gave the caution as its latest defined contribution statistics showed the number of members in master trusts has risen to 3.9 million - 80% of the total 4.7 million in automatic enrolment schemes. 

TPR's seventh annual statistics report on DC occupational pension schemes is based on data covering around 35,000 private pension schemes as of 31 December 2015.

TPR executive director for regulatory policy Andrew Warwick Thompson said in a statement today: "This poses some risk associated with regulatory arbitrage, with new master trusts being subject to far less regulatory scrutiny than new contract-based providers.

"We are working closely with the Department for Work and Pensions to ensure adequate member protections are in place within master trusts."

The revelation follows concerns that some recently introduced master trusts are not properly regulated. The Pensions Policy Institute warned last October about TPR's lack of power to discipline them. 

Last July, the regulator published a list of providers that were willing to take on small employers and met the voluntary master trust assurance framework (MAF), leading to talk that it was turning the screws on sub scale providers.

Just seven master trusts have been validated under the MAF, out of more than 80 providers. There have been calls to make the assurance framework mandatory.

 

 

More on Retirement

Partner Insight: The psychology of retirement

Partner Insight: The psychology of retirement

Bridging the advisers-clients gap: How emotional intelligence can help build deeper trust with clients and better understand their financial goals

James Woodfall, Raise Your El.
clock 15 September 2025 • 1 min read
Managing drawdown risk: A new frontier in retirement planning

Managing drawdown risk: A new frontier in retirement planning

'Volatility alone is no longer a sufficient risk measure'

Matthew Wright
clock 29 August 2025 • 4 min read
Sounding the alarm: Facing the retirement reality check

Sounding the alarm: Facing the retirement reality check

'At the heart of the issue is a worrying lack of engagement'

Laith Khalaf
clock 17 June 2025 • 3 min read

In-depth

'There are sharks out there': V11 footballer plight highlights professional athlete financial vulnerability

'There are sharks out there': V11 footballer plight highlights professional athlete financial vulnerability

‘Sadly, in every industry there is good and bad'

Jenna Brown
clock 03 September 2025 • 8 min read
Targeted support: 'Watch this space!' – unknowns persist

Targeted support: 'Watch this space!' – unknowns persist

Industry awaits final details of the FCA’s proposals

Isabel Baxter
clock 19 August 2025 • 7 min read
Polling high – should advisers bank on Reform UK holding on?

Polling high – should advisers bank on Reform UK holding on?

Nigel Farage-led party's policies would likely mean big tax changes if Reform came into power

Isabel Baxter
clock 30 July 2025 • 7 min read