Jupiter questions 'managed' pension fund poor performance

clock •

Jupiter Unit Trust Managers Limited has launched an attack on traditional managed pension funds, lambasting their poor performance and lack of courage to deviate from each other and their respective indices.

• '£1 billion plus' life company funds are performing poorly
• Personal pension investors need active fund management
• Jupiter SIPP offers investment diversity and potential for outperformance

Jupiter Unit Trust Managers Limited has launched an attack on traditional managed pension funds, lambasting their poor performance and lack of courage to deviate from each other and their respective indices.

Drawing on research, which demonstrates the poor performance of some of the largest life company managed funds, each holding more than a billion pounds of pension investors' money, Jupiter called for these 'managed' funds to begin investing people's money with a view to active outperformance, and for personal pension investors to consider their pension as an investment.

Five-year performance of the largest
three life company managed funds
Fund
5-year return (%)
Scottish Equitable Mixed -20
Standard Life Managed -18
Sun Life Managed -17
Average Managed Pension -12

Source: S&P Micropal, 01.10.97 – 01.10.02. Offer to bid, UK Pension,Based in UK Sterling, Calculation Indexed

Colin Maloney, Pension Development Director at Jupiter, said, "The major life offices have for too long dominated the investment of personal pension funds, and this has led to widespread complacency and lack of appetite to seek outperformance. During the long bull market of the 80s and 90s everyone made money, but the past few years have exposed the big managed pension funds as index huggers. Investors are starting to question their performance."

Jupiter's research also highlights the close correlation between the asset allocations of the UK's largest life office managed pension funds. The table below compares the largest three by their bonds, UK equities and overseas equities exposure.

Asset Allocation of largest
three life company managed funds
Scottish Equitable
Mixed (%)
Standard Life
Managed (%)
Sun Life
Managed (%)
Bonds 17.3 15.4 13.2
UK equities 52.5 53.3 54.7
Overseas equities 21.2 22.4 21.9

With life company difficulties falling increasingly under the spotlight, and poor performance driving down the value of investors' pension pots, Jupiter expects investment into self-invested personal pensions (SIPPs) to surge over the next five to ten years, as IFAs re-channel their clients' retirement savings into actively managed funds.

Maloney continued, "We want to explode the myth that life companies are for pensions and investment houses are for ISAs. Both ISAs and pensions are simply tax-efficient wrappers around what is by far the most important factor, the investment portfolio itself. SIPPs offer access to a diversity of investments, everything from collective funds to commercial property, thus enabling the construction of a balanced retirement portfolio*. Plus, with a genuinely active fund manager like Jupiter, pension investors give themselves the opportunity to outperform the markets and build up a comfortable retirement nest-egg."

The SIPPs market is already two thirds the size of the ISA market, representing £14bn of investors' money, however Jupiter is predicting further dramatic growth over the coming years.

Launched last year, the Jupiter SIPP offers price-competitive access to some of the best investment talent in the UK.

Jupiter Unit Trust Managers offers 28 retail unit trusts, with a core focus on UK and Europe. Investing in this range of funds can provide access to its leading fund of funds team as well as its two 'green' unit trusts which are researched by its long-established Environmental Research Unit. The funds are also available for investment within the Jupiter SIPP and the Jupiter Group provides private client services.

For further information please contact: Jupiter Broker Support Desk Jupiter Unit Trust Managers Ltd Tel: 020 7314 7699
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.jupiterifa.co.uk

IFAonline

More on Investment

Advisers urged to rethink role of traditional diversification

Advisers urged to rethink role of traditional diversification

Milliman publishes whitepaper

Sophia Panayi
clock 29 September 2026 • 2 min read

Active ETFs, ESG and the retirement advice challenge

Sarasin & Partners portfolio manager Ben Gilbert joins PA in the studio

Isabel Baxter
clock 05 June 2026 • 1 min read
Tyndall Partnerships head Sullivan on bespoke empowerment

Tyndall Partnerships head Sullivan on bespoke empowerment

‘No two IFAs invest in the same suite of models’

Isabel Baxter
clock 09 December 2024 • 4 min read

In-depth

Budget BADR changes could drive flurry of advice M&A but unlikely to hit valuations

Budget BADR changes could drive flurry of advice M&A but unlikely to hit valuations

Firms urged not to rush sales

Isabel Baxter
clock 09 November 2026 • 4 min read
PruFund's platform expansion: What next for the £73bn smoothed fund?

PruFund's platform expansion: What next for the £73bn smoothed fund?

Unpacking the flagship smoothed fund as it eyes more third-party platform launches

Isabel Baxter
clock 09 November 2026 • 7 min read
Advice JVs: Why professional services tie-ups are moving beyond referrals

Advice JVs: Why professional services tie-ups are moving beyond referrals

Firms look to joint brand relationships

Isabel Baxter
clock 27 August 2026 • 6 min read