Armchair Critic: The problem with 'advice' v 'guidance'

Beware near-synonyms

clock • 4 min read

Professional Adviser's Armchair Critic Brendan Llewellyn has this advice - or guidance - for any non-advisory service: call it what you will so long as its name and style do not imply the giving of advice

The Financial Advice Working Group's conclusions on the distinctions between advice and guidance is entirely incoherent and its recommendations on how to use the two terms is well set to fail. First, it is attempting to solve a problem that should not be there. Consumers need to know if they are being offered regulated financial advice. They need to know that, while it is still their decision, their adviser is offering the advice taking full account of their circumstances - it is personal advice. If it is not advice, there is no value in coining a term - guidance or otherwise. Still, if ...

To continue reading this article...

Join Professional Adviser for free

  • Unlimited access to real-time news, industry insights and market intelligence
  • Stay ahead of the curve with spotlights on emerging trends and technologies
  • Receive breaking news stories straight to your inbox in the daily newsletters
  • Make smart business decisions with the latest developments in regulation, investing retirement and protection
  • Members-only access to the editor’s weekly Friday commentary
  • Be the first to hear about our events and awards programmes

Join

 

Already a Professional Adviser member?

Login

More on Your profession

Charging deceased clients accidentally 'more common' than advice profession would like

Charging deceased clients accidentally 'more common' than advice profession would like

‘The fee outlives the service because the records do not talk to each other’

Sophia Panayi
clock 18 June 2026 • 4 min read
Reform for modern times: A fairer future for families

Reform for modern times: A fairer future for families

'Could reshape the legal and financial consequences of relationship breakdown'

Julia Peake
clock 17 June 2026 • 4 min read
Carla Brown: PFS will reassert itself as voice of the profession in 2026

Carla Brown: PFS will reassert itself as voice of the profession in 2026

PFS president and chair on building trust

Carla Brown
clock 16 June 2026 • 4 min read