Guaranteed versus reviewable - how much longer can the debate go on?

clock

It's changing times for the critical illness market - undoubtedly the most significant since this product was launched. The changes are being driven by advances in medical science and the claims experience of providers. Ultimately, the prevailing trends are likely to result in a new shape of product emerging in the medium to long term. In the short term however, the focus is on guaranteed rates versus reviewable rates.

A significant number of providers have now withdrawn guaranteed rates on stand alone critical illness cover and life with critical illness cover, with reviewable rates emerging as the alternative where guaranteed rates are not available.

The reality is that sooner rather than later guaranteed rates will disappear altogether, or become too prohibitively expensive to represent a viable option for many clients. No doubt that we are likely to see a major change to the shape and structure of critical illness products as we currently know them. However the industry is not yet clear on what this product development should look like.

In the meantime, it is worthwhile highlighting what IFAs should look for when recommending reviewable rates.

First of all, let's be clear that IFAs can make critical illness premiums more affordable for their clients in the short term by recommending reviewable rates instead of guaranteed rates. There is no doubt that reviewable premiums are cheaper in the short term. The differential between reviewable and guaranteed premiums is ever increasing, with many cases seeing a gap of upwards of 30%. This can be particularly significant to the client choosing to take out protection or not, particularly where a client has a restricted budget, such as a first time house buyer.

Reviewable rates are fixed for different periods with different providers. Some reviewable rates can be revised at any time. Among the most attractive options are five year reviewable rates which are fixed for five years and then reviewed, and then fixed for another five years, and so on. This enables the IFA to establish a greater expectation management with the client. It could also act as a catalyst for a regular financial health check with the client.

With reviewable rates there is no further need for underwriting after the initial application. The review is linked to the market at that time and not to the medical health of the client. In the future, if critical illness is to change, providers must ensure that critical illness cover maintains affordability and appropriateness. We must not allow the product to become so expensive as to exclude vast sections of the population from taking out cover. As consumer debt in the UK keeps rising, it is more important than ever before to address the "protection gap" which affects the population.

The overriding concern is that of IFA and client confidence – in the provider company, and in the protection industry as a whole, that the product they are buying will offer genuine value for money cover and will pay the expected benefit should critical illness arise.

Making sure that consumers understand the nature of the product they are buying is paramount for all parties to eliminate the potential for disappointment should a claim arise. It is important to acknowledge the pivotal role that the IFA can play in this. The protection market has entered an important new growth phase and we must avoid over complicating products going forward.

These are all future prospects. In the meantime, reviewable rates can represent an attractive alternative to rising guaranteed critical illness premiums.

Laura Shanks is product marketing manager at Scottish Equitable ProtectIFAonline

More on Protection

FCA to simplify insurance rules to 'support growth and innovation'

FCA to simplify insurance rules to 'support growth and innovation'

Further reviews waiting in the wings

Cameron Roberts
clock 09 December 2025 • 2 min read
Budget 25: The protection and health headlines

Budget 25: The protection and health headlines

NHS, welfare reform, NI, economic inactivity and more

Cameron Roberts
clock 27 November 2025 • 2 min read
Why life and income protection planning is essential for every business

Why life and income protection planning is essential for every business

Protecting livelihoods, relationships and the long term vision of a business

Ken Maxwell
clock 10 November 2025 • 4 min read

In-depth

The 'stark' impact of tax and pensions changes on special needs families

The 'stark' impact of tax and pensions changes on special needs families

Among hardest hit by ‘poorly consulted’ reforms

Jen Frost
clock 27 October 2025 • 8 min read
Reeves' rumoured ISA reforms risk 'harm' and diversification issues

Reeves' rumoured ISA reforms risk 'harm' and diversification issues

Concerns over rumoured £10k cash ISA cap and potential UK equity mandate

Sahar Nazir
clock 22 October 2025 • 5 min read
Rumoured Evelyn/RBC deal would turbocharge market share but large mergers 'notoriously complex'

Rumoured Evelyn/RBC deal would turbocharge market share but large mergers 'notoriously complex'

Sale ‘no surprise’ after Evelyn’s fund and professional services business offload

Isabel Baxter
clock 20 October 2025 • 6 min read