Industry Voice: The EM framing fallacy: Emerging market debt and the trials of a misunderstood asset class

clock • 5 min read

How we frame things deeply affects how we process information and subsequently act on it. So much so that, despite convincing evidence to the contrary, it can be extremely hard to shake off a fabled preconception. It seems that once a label sticks it can be very hard to dislodge.

Emerging markets are case in point. At worst, the label conjures up a misleading picture. At best, it fails to fully capture the nuances that lie behind each constituent country and issuer. Our behavioural quirks have conspired to lead many investors to structurally underweight emerging markets, particularly when it comes to allocating to debt.

Many of the facts that follow are well known but bear repeating if our cognitive errors are to be rebalanced.

Emerging markets now comprise around 60 per cent of the world's economy in GDP terms.1 Although developed world populations stagnate and atrophy, emerging market populations are young and fecund; approximately 85 per cent of the world's population, almost six and a half billion people, live in emerging markets.2

However, not only do they have young and vibrant workforces, the socioeconomic composition of their population is also shifting. The Brookings Institute has forecast the global middle class will double in the next ten years to reach 4.8 billion by 2030, with 79 per cent living in developing nations.3

Given their sheer demographic heft, it is perhaps unsurprising then that emerging markets are forecast to be the primary drivers of global growth in the years ahead. In its latest World Economic Outlook, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has estimated the difference in economic growth rates between emerging and developed markets will nearly double over the next five years to 3.2 per cent.4 Extrapolating on current growth rates and emerging markets' share of the global economy, the IMF expects their economies to contribute 84 per cent of global growth by 2024.5

Instruments within the emerging market debt universe have also proliferated - 257 per cent growth over the past decade - while the number of countries has jumped from 37 to 736 over the same period.

Time to take note - GCC benchmark addition

Growth within the emerging market debt universe accelerated further on 31 January when the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) officially joined the JP Morgan emerging market bond indices. The inclusion of sovereign and quasi-sovereign debt from Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain introduces a significant portion of highly-rated assets into the sovereign universe. Once the GCC phasing-in period completes in September 2019, around two-thirds of emerging market countries will be rated investment grade.

The skew towards investment grade can come as something of a surprise to many investors given the common perception that emerging market debt is a higher beta asset class and demonstrates the extent to which investor perceptions have failed to keep pace with reality. This gap has led to a structural mispricing of emerging market assets and can provide investors with attractive, steady, investment opportunities. By fully utilising the diverse universe of assets, active managers can adjust credit beta to provide a smoother path of strong risk-adjusted returns.

The increasing credit quality also strengthens the case for emerging market debt to become a structural holding rather tactical position within client portfolios.

Selectivity and investment discipline are still critical, however.  Currently, while the vast majority of higher-rated countries in the EM universe (those rated A, BBB and BB) have seen stable or improving credit metrics over the longer term, single-B rated countries in aggregate have experienced a deterioration. Geographic dispersion among the single-B names is significant, however, so country selection is key to generating attractive absolute and relative returns in this part of the EM universe.

Macro tailwinds

The macroeconomic environment also looks encouraging. Oil exporters are benefitting both from an uptick in the price of crude and, in the case of the GCC countries, from diversification efforts away from an over-reliance on petrochemicals to a more open and diversified economy. Oil prices have rallied by 40 per cent since the start of the year with Brent crude above $70 per barrel. Numerous indications, including conflict in Libya, Venezuela's economic and political implosion and tighter US sanctions on Iran, which came into effect on May 2, suggest prices have some way to go yet.

Shifting central bank rhetoric has provided a further tailwind. At its last meeting in March, the Federal Reserve reversed its previous plan for two interest rate rises in 2019. The majority of Federal Open Market Committee members now expect no hikes in 2019 and just one in 2020. The dovish tone has been mirrored elsewhere with the European Central Bank suggesting rates should remain on hold through year-end. China, Canada, Japan and Britain have likewise signalled an accommodative stance.

Strong technicals

Technical factors are also positive. To date, this year has seen strong inflows with a bias toward hard currency assets. Data from JP Morgan showed almost US$23 billion flowed into emerging market debt funds in the first quarter with US$10.2 billion in January alone; almost two thirds the amount recorded in the whole of 2018.7

Despite the recent rally, valuations are attractive and supply dynamics in the form of limited issuance, provide a further tailwind. As a result, hard currency sovereign debt has performed strongly since the start of the year returning over 7 per cent8 to the end of April.



Webinar: Emerging market debt - register today for Tuesday, 18 June, 2019

Join Liam Spillane, Head of Emerging Market Debt and Aaron Grehan, Deputy Head of Emerging Market Debt as they explain the case for emerging market debt, address key investor concerns and explore the optimal way of allocating to the asset class.



  1.[email protected]/OEMDC/ADVEC/WEOWORLD
  2.[email protected]/OEMDC/ADVEC/WEOWORLD
  6. Emerging Markets Bond Index (EMBI®) Monitor March 2019 Month-End
  8. J.P. Morgan Asset Management; data as of 9 April 2019:

More on Emerging Markets

Partner insight: China could see amazing improvements in productivity

Partner insight: China could see amazing improvements in productivity

Factory and agricultural automation will be needed to counteract China’s falling birth rate, says Capital Group’s Martyn Hole

Capital Group
clock 15 February 2022 • 1 min read
Industry Voice: Emerging markets' overlooked resilience

Industry Voice: Emerging markets' overlooked resilience

Horizon by Embark and Columbia Threadneedle
clock 17 November 2021 • 5 min read

Lessons from Turkey and Argentina: Where is the value in EMD now?

Industry Voice: Alejandro Arevalo, Manager of the Jupiter Global Emerging Markets Corporate Bond and Jupiter Global Emerging Markets Short Duration Bond Funds, discusses lessons learnt from recent crises in Turkey and Argentina this year, and how this...

Alejandro Arevalo, Manager of the Jupiter Global Emerging Markets Corporate Bond and Jupiter Global Emerging Markets Short Duration Bond Funds
clock 23 January 2019 • 5 min read


How much CPD for advisers is too much CPD for advisers?

How much CPD for advisers is too much CPD for advisers?

The pros and cons of continuing professional development

Justin Cash
clock 01 June 2023 • 4 min read
May 2023: Month in review with editor Hope William-Smith

May 2023: Month in review with editor Hope William-Smith

Take a look at some of the news and feature highlights of the last month

Hope William-Smith
clock 31 May 2023 • 3 min read
How advisers are bracing for the FSCS's revised levy demand

How advisers are bracing for the FSCS's revised levy demand

PA speaks to advisers on the impact of the FSCS revised levy demand

Sahar Nazir
clock 30 May 2023 • 5 min read