Royal London chief renews attack on plan to tax pensions like ISAs

Scott Sinclair
clock

The chief executive of life and investments provider Royal London has renewed his criticism of proposals to tax income saved into pensions like an ISA.

Phil Loney said the move risks undermining public confidence in long-term saving and "derailing" the government's achievements to date in the retirement sector.

"Nobody should be asked to save for 30+ years without absolute certainty that savings made from their income will not be taxed twice," the group CEO said.

Currently, tax relief on pension contributions is provided upfront as an incentive to keep money locked away until retirement, when contributions are subject to tax.

But Chancellor George Osborne has suggested reversing the system so that pension contributions are made from income already taxed. The savings would then be tax free when withdrawn.

But Royal London said the proposals would be damaging and urged the Treasury to focus its review on the current upfront tax relief model. It suggested an alternative could be a single rate of tax relief on a "2 for 1" basis.

"Creating a healthy savings habit amongst the UK public must be the ultimate goal of all who really care about preserving decent living standards in later life," said Loney.

"This is the rationale for Royal London's strong opposition to the proposal that income saved into pensions should be taxed like an ISA. Nobody should be asked to save for 30+ years without absolute certainty that savings made from their income will not be taxed twice.

"The public will not trust future cash strapped governments to honour any current promise of a tax free ISA style income in retirement."

Loney made the remarks as the group announced its nine-month sales results.

Increased pension sales, particularly a 52% rise in individual pension sales to more than £1.4bn, helped boost the group's overall new business by 35% in the nine months to the end of September, to £4.8bn.

More on Pensions

Gender pensions gap grows to £113,000

Gender pensions gap grows to £113,000

Report finds more than a third of women are likely to face poverty in retirement

Martin Richmond
clock 18 November 2025 • 3 min read
The FOMO-fuelled run on the pensions bank – where the Treasury is the only winner

The FOMO-fuelled run on the pensions bank – where the Treasury is the only winner

'You can't build a savings culture on a foundation of uncertainty'

Matt Storey
clock 17 November 2025 • 5 min read
Chancellor's potential salary sacrifice plan: A 'high risk gamble built on low quality data'

Chancellor's potential salary sacrifice plan: A 'high risk gamble built on low quality data'

Govt reportedly considering introducing a £2,000 salary sacrifice annual cap

Joseph Warne
clock 14 November 2025 • 4 min read

In-depth

The 'stark' impact of tax and pensions changes on special needs families

The 'stark' impact of tax and pensions changes on special needs families

Among hardest hit by ‘poorly consulted’ reforms

Jen Frost
clock 27 October 2025 • 8 min read
Reeves' rumoured ISA reforms risk 'harm' and diversification issues

Reeves' rumoured ISA reforms risk 'harm' and diversification issues

Concerns over rumoured £10k cash ISA cap and potential UK equity mandate

Sahar Nazir
clock 22 October 2025 • 5 min read
Rumoured Evelyn/RBC deal would turbocharge market share but large mergers 'notoriously complex'

Rumoured Evelyn/RBC deal would turbocharge market share but large mergers 'notoriously complex'

Sale ‘no surprise’ after Evelyn’s fund and professional services business offload

Isabel Baxter
clock 20 October 2025 • 6 min read