Armchair Critic: In search of the meaning of 'advice'

Why an ‘ought' or a ‘should' is so important

clock • 4 min read

In matters of finance, there is information and then there is advice - any other equivocation, argues Professional Adviser's Armchair Critic Brendan Llewellyn, is misguided and doomed

The Treasury has now announced a consultation on the meaning of advice, which is in part intended to open the market for the providers of guidance. Yet, only a few weeks earlier, the Financial Conduct Authority in the form of policy director David Geale said we should not get too hung up on the distinction between advice and guidance. And Michael Johnson, research fellow at think tank the Centre for Policy Studies, said this distinction between guidance and advice is ‘"complete bloody nonsense" because people in the street do not understand it. I would reverse the second statement - peop...

To continue reading this article...

Join Professional Adviser for free

  • Unlimited access to real-time news, industry insights and market intelligence
  • Stay ahead of the curve with spotlights on emerging trends and technologies
  • Receive breaking news stories straight to your inbox in the daily newsletters
  • Make smart business decisions with the latest developments in regulation, investing retirement and protection
  • Members-only access to the editor’s weekly Friday commentary
  • Be the first to hear about our events and awards programmes

Join

 

Already a Professional Adviser member?

Login

More on Your profession

Firm owners 'facing pressure' to make technology decisions

Firm owners 'facing pressure' to make technology decisions

‘AI is framed as something that will change everything’

Sahar Nazir
clock 30 January 2026 • 3 min read
Advisers urged to consider clients' 'trust state' and establish credibility early

Advisers urged to consider clients' 'trust state' and establish credibility early

‘Trust is built in moments of uncertainty, not certainty’

Isabel Baxter
clock 30 January 2026 • 3 min read
Cash ISA allowance cut risks hardening saver/investor divide, advisers warn

Cash ISA allowance cut risks hardening saver/investor divide, advisers warn

Govt policy shift reignites debate around role of cash ISAs

Sahar Nazir
clock 28 January 2026 • 5 min read