Approach to taxation on withdrawals a 'quiet scandal'

Over-taxation reclaims approaching £900m

Holly Roach
clock • 1 min read

The government’s approach to the taxation of pension withdrawals is a “quiet scandal”, according to AJ Bell.

The firm analysed HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) data, finding savers have been overtaxed around £892m since 2015. It said more than £33m was repaid to over 10,000 people overtaxed on pension withdrawals in April, May and June, with the government's monthly newsletter for July 2022 revealing the average reclaim sat at £3,363. Over-taxation occurs when savers flexibly access income from their retirement pot for the first time and are taxed on a ‘month one' basis, meaning usual tax allowances are divided by 12 and applied to the withdrawal. AJ Bell said this approach "risks exacerbating...

To continue reading this article...

Join Professional Adviser for free

  • Unlimited access to real-time news, industry insights and market intelligence
  • Stay ahead of the curve with spotlights on emerging trends and technologies
  • Receive breaking news stories straight to your inbox in the daily newsletters
  • Make smart business decisions with the latest developments in regulation, investing retirement and protection
  • Members-only access to the editor’s weekly Friday commentary
  • Be the first to hear about our events and awards programmes

Join

 

Already a Professional Adviser member?

Login

More on Pensions

Pension IHT: A minor win for executors, a missed opportunity for HMRC

Pension IHT: A minor win for executors, a missed opportunity for HMRC

'It's a great pity HMRC couldn't have been a bit braver and taken the sensible approach'

Rachel Vahey
clock 09 December 2025 • 3 min read
Salary sacrifice change to 'hit' more than three million workers

Salary sacrifice change to 'hit' more than three million workers

Government releases impact assessment

Jen Frost
clock 05 December 2025 • 3 min read
Andrew Tully: Plummeting pensions confidence is 'siren call' for wide-reaching action

Andrew Tully: Plummeting pensions confidence is 'siren call' for wide-reaching action

'We're seeing a deep erosion of trust in the retirement system'

Andrew Tully
clock 05 December 2025 • 3 min read