New research has criticised the suggestion by Adair Turner's Pension Report recommending compulsory pension saving as a means of alleviating the pension crisis.
According to consultancy firm Mercer HR, the rising flow in the price of UK housing has made it difficult for first-time buyers to meet any kind of savings requirement.
Mercer says the mortgage cost for a first-time buyer on an average income increased from 32% of net pay in 2002 to 41% in 2004 with the relative comparative cost of housing against salaries has eating any prospective contributions.
Mercer adds if interest rates were to increase by 1%, as predicted, then 45% of average take-home pay would be needed to pay a mortgage.
Dr Deborah Cooper says: "Turner has put forward a number of suggestions about how we can close the gap between hope and reality for pension savings. While compulsory pension saving sounds like a pragmatic solution, it is unaffordable and unrealistic, at least for some."
With the deadline closing yesterday for public submissions and responses to the October-published ‘Turner report’, Mercer points away from a compulsory pension system and instead urges for a ‘reformed’ state system where the basic state pension is combined with the flat rate state second pension to offer a single, flat rate, integrated state pension which increases in line with earnings.
Mercer argues such a system would have to be set at a level for most people to avoid means-tested top-ups, while the eligibility age should be at a level to make it affordable.
“People could then make supplementary contributions when they were able to, for example, when their mortgages have been paid,” Mecer says.IFAonline
‘Important to have an anchor’
Lack of innovation for solutions
Some 2,000 consumers affected
Achievements, charity work and other happy snippets