• Home
  • Multi-Asset
  •  
    Retirement
    • Pensions
    • Income
    • Investment
    • Regulation
    • Estate planning
    • Equity release
  •  
    Your profession
    • Adviser tips
    • Business models
    • Companies
    • People
  • Regulation
  • Tax planning
  • Protection
  • Diversity
  • Events
  • Whitepapers
  • Industry blogs
  • EM and Asia spotlight
  • Newsletters
  • ESG spotlight
  • Sign in
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      Professional Adviser's Working Lunches in partnership with Orbis Investments - 2019

      Join us in March for the Professional Adviser Working Lunch series in partnership with Orbis Investments.

      • Date: 05 Mar 2019
      • Knutsford, Leeds, Surrey, Bristol
      event logo
      Professional Adviser Working Lunches 2019 - Baillie Gifford & First State Investments

      Professional Adviser is delighted to announce the launch of the new Working Lunches in partnership with Baillie Gifford and First State Investments. Travelling across the UK to provide valuable market insights for Senior Financial Advisers.

      • Date: 13 Mar 2019
      • Southhampton, Worcester, Durham, Norwich, Liverpool, Exeter, Sheffield, Leicester, Nottingham
      event logo
      Professional Adviser 360 2019

      The highly anticipated Professional Adviser 360 conference is taking place on 25th April 2019 at The Brewery in London.

      • Date: 25 Apr 2019
      • The Brewery Chiswell Street London EC1Y 4SD, London
      event logo
      Fund Manager of the Year Awards 2019

      The 2019 Fund Manager of the Year returns on Thursday 27th June 2019, Grosvenor House Hotel, London. Save the date.

      • Date: 27 Jun 2019
      • Grosvenor House Hotel 86-90 Park Lane Mayfair London W1K 7TN, London
      View all events
      Follow our events

      Sign up to receive email alerts about our events

      Sign up
  • Whitepapers
    • Find whitepapers
      Search by title or subject area
      View all whitepapers
  • Sign in
  •  
    •  

      Personalise your on site experience

      Download and use the apps

      Access your subscription from outside of the office

      Get relevant news and insight straight to your inbox

      Sign in
     
     
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
  • Follow us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • YouTube
  • Register
  • Industry blogs
  • EM and Asia spotlight
  • ESG spotlight
Professional Adviser
Professional Adviser
  • Home
  • Multi-Asset
  • Retirement
  • Your profession
  • Regulation
  • Tax planning
  • Protection
  • Diversity
 
  •  

    Personalise your on site experience

    Download and use the apps

    Access your subscription from outside of the office

    Get relevant news and insight straight to your inbox

    Sign in
 
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
Professional Adviser

IMA accused of 'flawed' past performance report

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Google plus  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

Research published by the Investment Management Association has been criticized as 'flawed' because ...

Research published by the Investment Management Association has been criticized as 'flawed' because it suggests consumers can use past performance when selecting an appropriate investment as an indicator of potential future performance.


Stuart Fowler, investment industry consultant of Investment by Design, has accused the Investment Management Association of using data which does not reflect the typical analysis of advisers because the persistency of past performance is based on raw returns rather than risk-adjusted data, and does not include tracker funds.

Related articles

  • Government launches mid-life MOT website
  • Perspective buys northwest England IFA Investment Principles
  • Government will not 'force pace of change' in AE
  • AIG Life pays 99% life claims

Based on this second round of research produced by Charles River Associates, the IMA suggests funds from the UK All Companies and UK Equity Income funds across a 20-year period offer higher than random persistency over the long term.


Analysis of all funds over the last 20 years suggests funds which sit in the top quartile have a better than average chance of future top quartile performance, says the IMA.


Likewise, performance persisted over short periods for all four sectors tested - UK All Companies, UK Equity Income, UK Smaller Companies and UK Equity & Bond Income, says the IMA.


At best, however, there is a 45% persistency that funds being in the top quartile over a period will still be in the top quartile for the next period.


Fowler suggests CRA's raw analysis of around 940 funds between 1981 and 2001 has focused on the absolute returns of funds in some cases and taken some charges out in others.


"The argument [the IMA gives], that it replicates how investors actually use past performance, is appealing but plain wrong," says Fowler.


"Firstly investors and professional advisers do not pick 50 or more funds at once, and secondly, they are highly likely today to be benefiting from some kind of risk-adjusted selection process, such as the rating agencies' stars and rankings or the selection process of an IFA's 'best advice' panel. Indeed, the FSA's suitability regulations require some form of risk matching by advisers. For both advisers and self-directed investors, risk differentiation is commonly based on standard deviation or the Sharpe ratio, neither of which Charles River Associates even mention," he adds.


In a study of UK investment funds between 1981 and 2001, the IMA commissioned research to analyse raw returns, as consumers are more likely to look at returns on this basis.


CRA evidence highlights these two of the largest UK sectors showed performance and past performance "broadly persisted" in the 21-year period, says Richard Saunders, chief executive of the IMA.


"The IMA has always believed that past performance data can help investors and their advisers. This research, far more thorough than any previous study, shows conclusively that this belief is justified by the facts.


"These numbers do not show that picking last year's winner guarantees you out-performance next year. But they do suggest that, on average, past performance relative to peer group has a tendency to carry forward into the future, for both strong and weak performance. Thus, although past performance should never be the sole reason for choosing an investment fund, it cannot be ignored."


According to the IMA, if performance were based purely on random selection, at least 25% of funds could expect to achieve top quartile performance in that time, however, evidence shows persistent performance figures were in fact consistently higher.


The table below, compiled by CRA, shows the probability of a top quartile fund remaining in the top quartile, after initial and annual charges.











  UK All Cos UK Eq Inc UK Sm Cos UK Eq & B
 %%%%
12 months37.634.340.833.5
24 months29.431.332.427.5
36 months29.133.526.923.2
48 months29.739.222.226.9
60 months31.544.726.227.1
72 months33.042.732.227.7
84 months38.740.726.621.3

But Fowler still disputes these findings again, arguing an investor might need to invest in around 50 funds at a time in order to achieve these findings, rather than the one to three funds they might hold at any one time.


"Charles River should have calculated how many past top quartile funds you need to own in order to be reasonably sure of a better than random outcome. They needed to show whether holding the tiny number of funds most investors actually hold chances any different from random. You will not find any of this basic distribution analysis in the paper," continues Fowler.


To reader the IMA's full report - Performance persistence in UK equity funds - An empirical analysis" - click thru the right-hand link.


  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Google plus  
  • Send to  

More news

  • Retirement
Government launches mid-life MOT website

First mentioned in Cridland Report

  • 20 February 2019
Ian Wilkinson
  • Companies
Perspective buys northwest England IFA Investment Principles

Second acquisition of 2019

  • 20 February 2019
Guy Opperman
  • Regulation
Government will not 'force pace of change' in AE

Guy Opperman has rejected calls to speed up changes to auto-enrolment (AE) despite increasing pressure to boost contribution rates and overall savings pots.

  • 20 February 2019
Abbie Knight
  • Your profession
Abbie Knight: Get your business ready for the £5.5trn wealth transfer

Four key areas to focus on

  • 20 February 2019
  • Insurer
AIG Life pays 99% life claims

And 94% for critical illness

  • 20 February 2019
Back to Top

Most read

Woman and apps
How online 'nudges' are encouraging women to invest
Schroders and Lloyds unveil financial planning business
Abbie Knight
Abbie Knight: Get your business ready for the £5.5trn wealth transfer
Sean Kulan: How prepared are solo-regulated firms for SM&CR?
CEO of the IA Chris-Cummings
IA launches communication guide in response to FCA criticism
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy and Cookie policy
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • YouTube

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017