Dan Draper, head of ETFs at Credit Suisse, explains the reasons behind the launch of 45 ETFs in the UK
Last Wednesday saw the inaugural UK listing of Credit Suisse’s ETFs, including their “new generation” swap-based products.
The new funds encompass Credit Suisse’s 45 existing ETFs, available in Switzerland, Germany and Italy, covering mainstream traditionally-replicated indexes and 13 swap-based emerging market products, including the first ever UCITS Chinese A-Shares ETF listed in Europe, which tracks the CSI 300 index.
In pursuit of worldwide ETF growth, CS has formed a joint venture between its asset management and investment banking divisions to benefit from combined capabilities and bypass transaction fees.
Credit Suisse’s Dan Draper on launching UK ETFs
Dan Draper, head of ETFs at Credit Suisse emphasises the firm’s on-going commitment to traditional replication but explains some markets are more suited to swap-based products. “Emerging markets are a great candidate. Liquidity is very limited in many emerging markets so traditional replication relies on an optimised sample of the index or some degree of guesswork given time and currency differences. Both factors likely increase tracking error and volatility.”
In traditional replication investors bear the risk of higher tracking error. Not so with structured ETFs, Draper says: “For emerging markets, there is an opportunity cost for not using swap-based ETFs, which do not pass on tracking-error risk to the end customer. It transfers to the investment bank providing the swap.”
In return, however, investors are exposed to counter party risk. Under the joint venture, Credit Suisse Securities, with a Tier 1 capital ratio of 16.3% (as per June 30, 2010), is the sole counterparty for all 13 ETFs.
“Ucits limits counterparty risk to 10%,” Draper explains, “but our ETFs also reset daily and are marked-to-market.”
While intraday volatility could affect counterparty risk, in traditionally replicated ETFs it increases tracking-error risk.
“For our funds, counterparty risk resets to zero at the end of every trading day and clients know the fund resets to 100% of the index value after the market closes, even if things go pear-shaped.
“The investors’ basket of assets is also completely transparent, published on our website and composed of blue-chip equities. The return from this basket is ‘swapped’ for the exact return of the ETF’s emerging market index.”
Because many ETFs reset weekly or monthly, Draper argues, Credit Suisse clients benefit from greater transparency. “Less frequent resetting means counterparty risk can linger and fund values can change. You know what you own as a Credit Suisse ETF investor and you know the value of that collateral will equal 100% of the index value you are tracking every day. This is the highest level of transparency and quality in the market.”
According to Credit Suisse research, transparency regarding underlying assets and counterparty risk is paramount for investors considering synthetic versus full replication.
“By resetting daily and publishing synthetic ETFs’ holdings on the website, we are introducing a new concept,” Draper says. “This level of transparency is crucial, which is supported by direct client feedback and regulatory trends.”
Many of Credit Suisse’s clients are active, institutional managers. “These guys just want efficient ETFs that work without nasty surprises,” Draper says. “They spend time up-front to ensure they are selecting ETFs with the highest levels of transparency and risk management. Beyond that they want to focus most of their energy and resources generating alpha.”
According to Draper, ETFs also empower retail investors by providing access to portfolio management tools previously only available to institutions. “It is a real development in how people save and plan for their future,” he says. “Much like healthcare, people are now required to become more informed to take advantage of the best options available. Future generations need to be much more financially savvy as the increasing retirement age and decreasing state benefits place more onus on self-directed investment and planning.”
Although retail investors have been slower to adopt ETFs outside the US, regulatory tendencies look favourable. The UK’s Retail Distribution Review laid the groundwork for a shift towards fee-based rather than commission-driven advice, making inexpensive ETFs attractive.
“Australian and other European regulators are looking in the same direction,” Draper says. “We now need more education for IFAs to develop the necessary portfolio management skills. In effect, as a tool, ETFs have developed faster than the IFA business model.”
For many retail investors, however, the pace of development and increased complexity in the ETF market will set alarm bells ringing.
“It is important to remember these are UCITS funds, not structured products or notes,” Draper emphasises. “These are funds with boards of directors, fiduciaries who oversee their running on investors’ behalf. It is important to stress the corporate governance and fiscal advantages of using a UCITS fund over a note.”
Formally combing Credit Suisse’s established might in fund management and structured finance gives the firm a considerable edge, Draper believes:
“By forming a 50/50 joint venture we are bringing together the infrastructure and trust of the asset management business with the structuring and liquidity capabilities of the investment bank. Considering the changing evolution of the industry and regulation, the better long-term strategy for ETF growth is to really combine the best capabilities of the entire bank.
“Ultimately, ETFs are about providing the highest quality and most efficient tools for people of all levels to increase the probability of achieving their long-term financial goals,” Draper concludes. “This is a very forward-looking part of the industry and Credit Suisse wants to play a leading role.”
Draper joined Credit Suisse earlier this year from Lyxor Asset Management, where he was managing director and Global Head of ETFs. Prior to this, Draper was the director of UK and Ireland Business Development at iShares, the ETF arm of Barclays Global Investors now owned by BlackRock.
Putting the tech into protection
Square Mile’s series of informal interviews
Fallout from Haywood suspension
Launching later in 2019
£80bn funds under calculation